-MONTHLY VHS & DVD REVIEW-
copyright © 2001 - 2005 VideoVista
Episode listing -
Something Wicca This Way Comes
I've Got You Under My Skin
Thank You For Not Morphing
Dead Man Dating
The Wedding From Hell
The Fourth Sister
The Truth Is Out There... And It Hurts
The Witch Is Back
Feats Of Clay
Fear To Eternity
Secrets And Guys
Is There A Woogy In The House?
Which Prue Is It, Anyway?
That '70s Episode
When Bad Warlocks Go Good
Out Of Sight
The Power Of Two
Deja Vu All Over Again
Charmed: season one|
cast: Holly Marie Combs, Shannen Doherty, and Alyssa Milano
creator: Constance M. Burge
972 minutes (12) 1998
Paramount DVD Region 2 retail
reviewed by Martin Drury
The premise of Charmed is simple. Three attractive women live in a slightly odd
looking house in an affluent area of America. These young women are the Halliwell sisters.
Prue, Phoebe and Piper. The Halliwells hide a secret that stretches back through generation
after generation of their family, forming the roots of their family tree. The Halliwell
sisters are witches. Prue, Phoebe and Piper are the 'Charmed Ones', gifted with the
'power of three' and tasked with protecting humanity from the interference and influence
of a menagerie of evil warlocks, demons and boyfriends behaving as jerks.
The premise of the series is preposterous and the Halliwell sisters are perpetually clad
in glamour-queen outfits despite apparently living fairly normal lives. Yet, for some
reason, none of that matters. The first season is the weakest as it is responsible for
establishing characters, relationships and situations. It's also got Shannen Doherty
in it. Prue is the weakest link in the Halliwell sister line-up and Doherty's portrayal
of the wiccan matriarch as a frustrated beauty queen masquerading as a mother-hen causes
amusement in place of amazement. The show is built on magic. Doherty's performance was
constructed through ennui.
The season is presented well on DVD with picture and sound quality both punching above
their weight. The subtitles, menus and episode dialogue can all be presented to the
viewer in a variety of different languages (through selection from the main disc menu).
Episode selection is simple and there's the traditional option to play all. The working
relationship between Combs, Milano and Doherty was not exactly amicable throughout the
recording of the first series of Charmed and as such tensions can be detected in
the performances, which distract from the introduction to the weird world of the sisters
and their battles against evil.
Charmed comes into its own only when Rose McGowan joins the cast as Paige and
that's not for many seasons beyond season one. The love triangles and romance stories
involving the Halliwell sisters are rarely accessible for a male audience to engage
with and ironically the only time the show introduces a strong male character, he turns
out to be the source of all wickedness. The 'good guys' look like lapdogs and most of
the male characters in the first few seasons of Charmed had impossibly chiselled
chins and trademarked haircuts.
Charmed attempted to cross many boundaries in its first season, particularly as
far as television genres were concerned. The inclusion of the police Inspector 'Andy'
as an ally for the Charmed Ones as they go about solving 'otherworldly crimes' forced
the show onto NYPD Blue territory, bringing about an uncomfortable and unintentional
parody of American cop shows. For the most part, the performances of the actresses are
above par but the writing is often cliché ridden. Sometimes, it's as if someone
bought all the 'teen wicca' books in the shop, gouged them and threw the words back
into a script for Charmed season one. If you're a fan, then you've already got
season two on pre-order and nobody can talk you out of it. If you're a casual viewer,
tune to Channel 5 or Living TV instead as you'll most likely see most of the episodes
on this release repeated ad nausea. Wait for the McGowan factor before you invest in
the lives of these three troubled witches.